The wider picture
Daniel Tomassetti was arrested in Mexico on August 1, 2025, after being a fugitive for nearly nine years. He is wanted in connection with the murders of Mila Barberi and Angelo Musitano, both of whom were shot dead in 2017. Tomassetti’s arrest marks a significant development in a case that has haunted law enforcement and the victims’ families for years.
Barberi was shot outside a Vaughan business on March 14, 2017, at the age of 28, while Musitano was killed on May 2, 2017, at the age of 39. Following these tragic events, Tomassetti was placed under police surveillance and subsequently fled to Cancun, Mexico, in January 2018. He had been listed on Canada’s most wanted list, and Hamilton Police even issued a $50,000 reward for information leading to his arrest.
Tomassetti is contesting extradition back to Canada, where he faces serious charges: two counts of first-degree murder, one count of attempted murder, and three counts of conspiracy to commit murder. His legal team argues that the evidence provided by Canadian authorities may not meet the necessary standards under Mexican law.
York Regional Police confirmed that Tomassetti is currently detained in Mexico, and they are working with Mexican authorities to secure his extradition. “He is being detained and an extradition order is being sought,” a spokesperson for York Regional Police stated.
Detective Sergeant Jason Cattle emphasized the ongoing impact of the case on the Barberi family, stating, “This is something that is still ongoing for them and always will for the rest of their lives, and there’s one person that’s still outstanding that was involved in their daughter’s murder.” This highlights the emotional toll that the unresolved cases have had on the victims’ families.
As the extradition process unfolds, legal experts note that Canada must provide sufficient evidence to justify Tomassetti’s return. Jeff Hershberg, a legal analyst, commented, “Essentially the requesting state, which is Canada, simply just has to provide sufficient evidence to justify the arrest and his committal under the Mexican law.” This process could take time, and observers are closely monitoring the developments.
Details remain unconfirmed regarding the specifics of Tomassetti’s arrest and the evidence that may be presented in the extradition hearings. Meanwhile, the families of the victims await justice, hoping that this arrest will lead to a resolution in a case that has lingered for far too long.
With Tomassetti’s capture, law enforcement agencies are hopeful that they can finally bring closure to the families affected by these brutal crimes. The next steps in the extradition process will be crucial in determining whether he will face trial in Canada for the alleged murders.